Best Pet Insurance in 2025: Complete Buyer’s Guide
Last Updated: August 2025 | By the Sibete Insurance Team
Quick Summary: Top Pet Insurance Picks
| Provider | Best For | Monthly Cost | Coverage Limit | Deductible |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lemonade | Overall Value | $25-70 | Up to Unlimited | $100-500 |
| Pets Best | Budget-Conscious | $20-50 | $5K-Unlimited | $50-1000 |
| ASPCA | Comprehensive Coverage | $30-80 | Up to Unlimited | $100-500 |
| Embrace | Wellness Plans | $35-75 | $5K-Unlimited | $200-1000 |
| Figo | Tech-Savvy Owners | $30-70 | $5K-Unlimited | $100-750 |
What Makes Pet Insurance “Best”?
When evaluating the best pet insurance options in 2025, we analyzed over 20 providers based on:
✅ Coverage breadth – accidents, illnesses, hereditary conditions
✅ Pricing transparency – no hidden fees or surprise costs
✅ Claim processing speed – how quickly you get reimbursed
✅ Customer satisfaction – real user reviews and ratings
✅ Veterinarian acceptance – works with your preferred vet
#1 Best Overall: Lemonade Pet Insurance
Why We Recommend It:
- Fast Claims: AI-powered claims processing in minutes
- Transparent Pricing: No price increases based on claims
- Comprehensive Coverage: Accidents, illnesses, behavioral therapy
- Flexible Plans: 70%, 80%, or 90% reimbursement options
Best For: First-time pet owners who want simple, transparent coverage
Pricing: $25-70/month depending on pet, location, and coverage level
Coverage Includes:
- Emergency visits and hospitalization
- Diagnostic tests (X-rays, MRIs, bloodwork)
- Surgeries and specialist treatments
- Prescription medications
- Physical therapy and rehabilitation
What’s Not Covered: Pre-existing conditions, preventive care (unless you add wellness plan)
Lemonade is especially popular with dog owners due to their comprehensive coverage of common canine conditions. Learn more about the best dog insurance options.
#2 Best Budget Option: Pets Best
Why It’s Great for Budget-Conscious Owners:
- Low Starting Price: Plans start at just $20/month
- Flexible Deductibles: Choose from $50-$1000 annual deductible
- Direct Vet Pay: Option to pay your vet directly
- 24/7 Pet Helpline: Included with all plans
Best For: Cost-conscious pet parents who still want solid coverage
Coverage Highlights:
- Accidents and illnesses
- Cancer treatments
- Hereditary and congenital conditions
- Emergency care
Pets Best offers excellent value for both dogs and cats. Compare Pets Best with other budget-friendly options.
#3 Most Comprehensive: ASPCA Pet Health Insurance
Why It Stands Out:
- Complete Care Coverage: Optional wellness plans for routine care
- No Upper Age Limits: Covers pets throughout their lifetime
- Behavioral Coverage: Includes behavioral treatments
- Multiple Pet Discounts: Save 10% with multiple pets
Best For: Pet owners who want the most complete coverage possible
Unique Benefits:
- Covers alternative therapies (acupuncture, chiropractic)
- Behavioral modification treatments
- Prescription diet foods for medical conditions
Best Pet Insurance by Pet Type
🐕 Best for Dogs
Winner: Embrace Pet Insurance
- Breed-specific coverage considerations
- Hip dysplasia and joint condition coverage
- Wellness plans include dental cleaning
[Internal link to: sibete.com/best-pet-insurance-for-dogs/]
🐱 Best for Cats
Winner: Pets Best
- Covers common feline conditions (kidney disease, hyperthyroidism)
- Indoor cat discounts available
- Covers dental disease treatment
[Internal link to: sibete.com/best-pet-insurance-for-cats/]
🐶 Best for Puppies
Winner: Lemonade
- No waiting period for accidents
- Covers puppy-specific issues
- Vaccination and spay/neuter coverage with wellness plan
How Much Does Pet Insurance Cost?
Average Monthly Costs by Pet Type:
- Dogs: $35-70/month
- Cats: $15-40/month
- Puppies (under 1 year): $25-50/month
- Senior pets (7+ years): $45-100/month
Factors That Affect Your Premium:
- Pet’s Age: Younger pets = lower premiums
- Breed: Some breeds have higher genetic risks
- Location: Urban areas typically cost more
- Coverage Level: Higher reimbursement = higher premium
- Deductible: Higher deductible = lower monthly cost
For a detailed breakdown of costs by provider, see our complete pet insurance comparison chart.
What Does Pet Insurance Actually Cover?
✅ Usually Covered:
- Accidents: Broken bones, cuts, poisoning, car accidents
- Illnesses: Cancer, diabetes, kidney disease, infections
- Emergency Care: After-hours vet visits, hospitalization
- Diagnostic Tests: X-rays, MRIs, ultrasounds, bloodwork
- Surgeries: Both emergency and planned procedures
- Prescription Medications: Antibiotics, pain medications, chronic condition drugs
- Specialist Treatments: Oncology, cardiology, orthopedics
❌ Usually NOT Covered:
- Pre-existing Conditions: Any condition your pet had before coverage started
- Preventive Care: Routine checkups, vaccinations (unless you add wellness)
- Grooming: Cosmetic procedures, nail trimming
- Breeding Costs: Pregnancy, birthing complications
- Experimental Treatments: Unproven or investigational procedures
How to Choose the Right Pet Insurance Plan
Step 1: Assess Your Pet’s Needs
- Young, healthy pet: Focus on accident and basic illness coverage
- Breed with known issues: Ensure hereditary conditions are covered
- Senior pet: Look for comprehensive illness coverage
- Multiple pets: Find providers with multi-pet discounts
Step 2: Set Your Budget
- Monthly premium: What can you comfortably afford?
- Deductible: Annual amount you pay before insurance kicks in
- Reimbursement level: 70%, 80%, or 90% of covered costs
Step 3: Compare Key Features
- Coverage limits: Annual or per-incident maximums
- Waiting periods: How long before coverage starts
- Claim process: Online, mobile app, or phone-based
- Vet network: Does it work with your current vet?
Pet Insurance vs. Pet Savings Account
Pet Insurance Pros:
✅ Immediate coverage for large unexpected bills
✅ Predictable monthly costs
✅ Access to expensive treatments you might not afford
✅ Peace of mind for emergency situations
Pet Insurance Cons:
❌ Monthly premiums even when not using it
❌ Doesn’t cover pre-existing conditions
❌ Deductibles and co-pays
❌ Some exclusions and waiting periods
Pet Savings Account Pros:
✅ You keep the money if not used
✅ Covers everything (including preventive care)
✅ No claim approvals needed
✅ Earns interest over time
Pet Savings Account Cons:
❌ Takes time to build up funds
❌ Large emergency bills could drain account
❌ Requires discipline to save consistently
❌ No coverage for immediate emergencies
Bottom Line: Pet insurance is better for unexpected large expenses, while savings accounts work well for routine care and small emergencies.
State-by-State Pet Insurance Guide
High-Cost States (Higher Premiums):
- California: $45-85/month average
- New York: $40-80/month average
- Massachusetts: $40-75/month average
Moderate-Cost States:
- Texas: $30-60/month average
- Florida: $35-65/month average
- Illinois: $30-65/month average
Budget-Friendly States:
- Ohio: $25-50/month average
- Georgia: $25-55/month average
- North Carolina: $25-50/month average
Find the best pet insurance in California →
Compare Florida pet insurance options →
Best pet insurance providers in Texas →
Frequently Asked Questions
Is pet insurance worth it?
Yes, for most pet owners. The average lifetime veterinary costs for dogs range from $15,000-25,000, and cats $10,000-18,000. Pet insurance helps make expensive treatments affordable when your pet needs them most.
When should I get pet insurance?
As early as possible. Puppies and kittens have the lowest premiums and no pre-existing conditions. Ideally, get coverage within the first few weeks of adopting your pet.
Can I use any veterinarian?
Most pet insurance companies let you use any licensed vet in the US and Canada. Some even cover emergency visits while traveling internationally.
How do I file a claim?
Most modern providers offer mobile apps where you can upload photos of receipts and get reimbursed within days. The typical process:
- Pay your vet bill upfront
- Submit claim through app or website
- Get reimbursed to your bank account
What’s a pre-existing condition?
Any health issue your pet had before your policy started, or during the waiting period. This includes symptoms of conditions that weren’t diagnosed yet.
Do premiums increase over time?
Most companies increase premiums as your pet ages, typically starting around age 7-8. However, some providers like Lemonade promise never to raise rates based on claims filed.
Getting Started: Your Next Steps
1. Get Quotes (Takes 5 minutes)
Compare personalized quotes from our top-rated providers:
- Enter your pet’s age, breed, and zip code
- Compare coverage options side-by-side
- No commitment required
2. Read the Fine Print
- Waiting periods for different conditions
- Exclusions and limitations
- Claim filing requirements
- Cancellation policies
3. Start Coverage ASAP
Don’t wait for an emergency. Most policies have waiting periods:
- Accidents: 2-14 days
- Illnesses: 14-30 days
- Orthopedic conditions: 6-12 months
Related Guides
- Best Pet Insurance for Dogs – Breed-specific recommendations and coverage for common dog health issues
- Best Pet Insurance for Cats – Feline-focused plans covering kidney disease, hyperthyroidism, and more
- Pet Insurance Comparison Tool – Side-by-side comparison of all major providers with pricing
- Cheapest Pet Insurance Options – Budget-friendly plans that still provide solid coverage
This guide is updated regularly to reflect the latest pet insurance offerings and pricing. Last updated: August 2025.